The Book Mine Set

Book discussion blog with a Canadian bias.

My Photo
Name:
Location: Yellowknife, Northwest Territories, Canada

I've lived North of 60 for 10 years, I have 1 wife, 2 kids, and 1,245,607 books tbr.

Monday, May 30, 2011

Reader's Diary #718- José Eduardo Agualusa: If Nothing Else Helps, Read Clarice

Looking for online African short stories, I came upon the Woyingi Blog, which has a fantastic list of African authors, organized by country. You have to skim for short story authors, but there are many links to short stories available online. Hoping to consult this list on a pretty regular basis, I figured I'd start with the very first link: Angolian author José Eduardo Agualusa's "If Nothing Else Helps, Read Clarice." (As it turns out, Agualusa and I share the same birthday-- though he's 16 years older than I.)

If Nothing Else Happens, Read Clarice begins with a man disillusioned by television and deciding instead to dream up a fish. It's a skill he once learned from an old fisherman and the rest of the story recounts that lesson.

Dancing lightly with magical realism, I was apprehensive. It's not a form that I actively seek out and admittedly I feel stupid when I can't figure out what the heck it's all supposed to mean, which is quite often. Is it symbolic? Is it fantasy? I want to appreciate it for the creativity involved, but my logical side wants to ram a flaming Q-Tip into my brain. My logical side.

But in the absence of matches and cotton swabs, I instead filled in the logical gaps of Agualusa's story with assumptions. Dreaming up a fish is just using one's imagination. But more than that, it's using imagination as meditation. Drawing in bits of ones surroundings to help create an internal image of a perfect fish, detailed and real. Or else the old fisherman is crazy. Or crazy, but on to something.

It might help if I'd read Clarice. Clarice Lispector is a Brazilian author who I'd not heard of before, but fortunately I was also able to find one of her short stories online. (She's also a Sagittarius.) So, next Monday, I'll see if it all makes a little more sense. And if it doesn't, this week's story was pleasant enough as it was.

(Did you write a post for Short Story Monday? If so, please leave a link in the comments below!)

Labels: , , , ,

Blogger Julie @ Read Handed said...

Sounds like an interesting story. I posted this week about Dennis Lehane's short stories. You can read it here

Monday, 30 May, 2011  
Blogger Loni said...

Not sure if this is a story I'm going to read. I'm also apprehensive about magical realism. I like to mostly understand what I'm reading.

I read Ponies this week
http://loniseye.blogspot.com/2011/05/ponies-by-kij-johnson.html

Monday, 30 May, 2011  
Blogger Melwyk said...

I haven't read this short story yet -- thanks for pointing it out. I read Agualusa's novella Book of Chameleons a while back and quite liked it!

Tuesday, 31 May, 2011  

Saturday, May 28, 2011

Saturday Word Play: Northwords Festival Logic

The 6th Annual Northwords Festival takes over Yellowknife in less than a week. In honour of Kathy Reichs, one of this year's headliners, here's a little mystery to get you in the mood. Use the clues below to solve the logic problem: Match the author with the title and workshop* they'll be hosting. (For more of this year's events and authors make sure to check out the Northwords website-- but not until after you solve the logic problem or else you'll see all the answers!)


1. The author that wrote Nice Recovery, a memoir about recovering from alcoholism, is hosting the Writing For Teens workshop.
2. Neither Charlotte Gray nor Ted Staunton are hosting the Poetics of Poetry workshop.
3. Kathy Reichs is the author of Deja Dead and is hosting a Crime Fiction talk (*I've been informed by a couple of Northwords members that hers is not a workshop, as I'd indicated earlier. It's actually a luncheon/discussion. For the sake of this puzzle, however, count it as a workshop.)
4. Gregory Scofield is the author of either Kipocihkan or Puddleman, but is not the host of the Life to History Workshop or Picture This.
5. Susan Juby is not the author of Puddleman, nor the host of Life to History.
6. The Picture This Workshop is either hosted by Ted Staunton or the author of Kipocihkan.
7. The Puddleman author is not the host of the Poetics of Poetry.
8. The host of the Life to History Workshop is also the author of Gold Diggers.

It'll help to print off the grid above and put a check mark in all the ones you know are correct, and an X in all those you know are not. Good luck! Write your answer in the comments below!

Labels: , , ,

Blogger gypsysmom said...

I can't believe I'm the first to leave a comment. This can't have stumped everyone else. To honour the usual rules of Saturday Word Play I'll only give one answer.

Ted Staunton is hosting Picture This and is the author of Puddleman (at least that's the way the grid works out for me).

Have fun at the festival. Sounds great.

Sunday, 29 May, 2011  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Gypsysmom: That's correct!

Sunday, 29 May, 2011  

Thursday, May 26, 2011

Reader's Diary #717- William Shakespeare: Cymbeline

It took Charlotte's post over at Inklings about independent bookstores and her thoughts on eReader sales to remind me that I haven't reviewed Shakespeare's Cymbeline yet, though I finished it over a month ago.

First, the eBook connection. For the most part I prefer reading real books. But when I'm traveling I'd rather go with a bunch loaded up on my Reader. (Though the first time I heard the flight attendant say "Can you please turn of your book? We're getting ready to descend?" I found it a little jarring.) Also, when my hard copy of The Complete Works of William Shakespeare weighs and takes up as much space as a couple of bricks, it's much easier to read it on the eReader. Though a word of advice to publishers, if it's in the public domain why not offer it as a free download? You might lose a small profit by having to pay someone to format it, but you don't have to pay an author. Give that away for free and you'll entice people like me to your site, I'll get that one and probably buy another book or two while I'm there, meaning you'll make money in the long run. My entire eVersion of the Complete Works of Sheakespeare by project Gutenberg is free. At the Sony eReader store they have a copy of the complete works for $7.99. Not bad, but why pay at all when I can get it for free? It's not it comes in a fine leather bound edition that'll look all fancy on my book shelf. It gets even worse when you buy the separate plays-- averaging about $4 each, or $148 dollars for the complete set. Again, it's not like a real book where you don't want the entire volume cramping your hand when you just want to read the Tempest. With the eVersion of the Complete Works doesn't make your eReader any heavier than a single play, and again, it's free. What idiots would pay for electronic Shakespeare books? What idiots would expect you to?

Rant over.

Anyway, Cymbeline isn't one of Shakespeare's better known plays but I can't see any reason for that. For fans of Shakespeare, it's a very Shakespearean play. Love, betrayal, jealousy, disguises, royalty, a thirst for power. You know, the typical stuff. Based on legends of Celtic British royalty, it's a tough plot to summarize. For now, the Wikipedia synopsis will suffice. (It also helped me keep everyone straight.) One small annoyance: when Cymbeline's daughter runs away, disguises herself in drag and comes across her step-brothers, also in exile, and neither knows the other. We, the audience, are quite aware of the set-up and the scene could be rife with humour, awkwardness, anything. Unfortunately the situation is milked for all it's worth and comes across as silly and phony more than anything else. They bond right away and refer to one another as brothers, men, and so on. It should work, but it's run into the ground.

But it's Shakespeare and at his worst, he's still entertaining. And Cymbeline is not is his worst. The fidelity bet alone is worth the price of admission. It's a soap opera moment, yes, but when it's surrounded by Shakespearean wit, that kind of stuff is not only tolerated, it's welcomed.

Labels: , ,

Blogger Biblibio said...

Great point about the price for formatting. I much prefer to get my public domain eBooks unformatted and messy than start paying money for something that should, by all rights, be absolutely free... That kind of move by publishers would probably put them in my good books and encourage me to splurge on them on other occasions.

As for who would actually pay, I suppose readers for whom the aesthetics are crucial. I'm not of that mindset (I'm stingy...), but I can imagine that for some, the elegance might be worth a few bucks. The only real advantage I can think of is the footnote potential - that might make it worth it.

Sunday, 29 May, 2011  

Wednesday, May 25, 2011

The Great Wednesday Compare- FINALE


The winner of last week's Great Wednesday Compare (Anne Shirley VERSUS Marilla Cuthbert), with a final score of 8-1 was Marilla Cuthbert.

This is bizarre! I have to say, I did not predict that at all. The winner of the Great Wednesday Compare #7, Marilla Cuthbert, beat the winner of the Great Wednesday Compare #8, Anne Shirley, and by a landslide. That both these women ended up on top in the first place is strange enough, but Mr. Miyagi beating the Karate Kid? I didn't see that coming.

But I'm glad the final outcome still held a surprise for me. It's a good note to go out on. Yes, I'm retiring the Great Wednesday Compares. At least for now. I've done books, I've done bookish things, and I've done characters and I think I'm done. It's been a lot of fun and I love that so many people played along. Thank you so much. In the meantime, stay tuned for my next weekly feature: drawing Victorian authors in inappropriate poses! No? How about recipes based on the Earth's Children series? Maybe not. Timothy Findley impersonations? I've got nothing.

Labels:

Blogger Loni said...

Awe, so sad... Well, it was fun while it lasted.

Wednesday, 25 May, 2011  
Blogger Bybee said...

It's the end of an era.

Wednesday, 25 May, 2011  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

Wednesdays will never be the same.

Wednesday, 25 May, 2011  
Blogger Allison said...

How am I suppose to be able to tell it's Wednesday now? Use an actual calender? Boo. ;)

Thursday, 26 May, 2011  
Blogger C.B. James said...

Though I was only an occasional participant, I did enjoy The Great Wednesday Compare. Thanks for them all.

Friday, 27 May, 2011  
Blogger raidergirl3 said...

I bet Marilla beats everything - any book, any taker, ever.

thanks for all the fun John. I know it was a lot of work, but it was appreciated.

Friday, 27 May, 2011  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Again, thank-you to everyone for your kind words in this time of sorrow.

Friday, 27 May, 2011  
Blogger Nicola said...

I'm just hearing the news! RIP to the Great Wednesday Compare. It will never be the same again ...

Sunday, 29 May, 2011  

Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Reader's Diary #716- Nils Andrew Thompson: Looking for Momo in Tomo Domo

For the 10th update of the 4th Canadian Book Challenge I announced that if we read and reviewed 10 or more Canadian books with a Japanese connection, I'd donate $200 to the Red Cross for their earthquake relief efforts. If we came up less than 10 books, I'd donate $10 per book. Nils Andrew Thompson's Looking for Momo in Tomo Domo is my contribution.

Thompson, like many Canadians, went to Japan to teach English. Looking for Momo in Tomo Domo records his yearlong experience. It's at once a travelogue, a teacher's journal, and even a romance.

Thompson's style is amusing for the most part, but the corny jokes lose their charm after a while. In one scene, for instance, he asks his Japanese girlfriend for a kiss, chu in Japanese. It was the 2nd time the word had caused them a problem-- the 1st time around it was Thompson's turn to learn the word. This time it was his attempt at using it that caused the communication breakdown. His girlfriend had just brought him presents:
"I brought you presents."
Yummy! She carried a bag that appeared to be full of gifts.
"Chew," I offered.
"Maybe, you must open them to see."
"No... a thank-you chew," I stressed.
"Chew?"
"Chu, chu," I clarified, puckering my lips.
"Ah chu," she replied laughing.
We chewed.
Chuga, chuga, choo, choo!


An amusing enough anecdote without the last cornball line thrown in. The more of these he wrote, the more irritating they became. Probably because I'm guilty of such lame jokes myself. Typical dad jokes, though Thompson wasn't a dad at the time and they don't really serve any purpose in a book. But, I told myself, that wasn't the point of the book-- an apology I've been making for a lot of non-fiction lately. Which leads me to an important question: should non-fiction writing be held to a lower standard than fiction writing because the information supersedes the expression?


Supposing the answer is yes,I'm still not sure Thompson's book is off the hook. Certainly it would give a Canadian some sense of the culture and our differences and similarities, but some of it is quite dated, even though it was published only 10 years ago. This is most apparent when he discusses cellphones. "The portable telephones were rampant," he writes. Apparently shocked over the addiction people had to their phones, I wonder what he thinks of the iPhone epidemic in Canada 10 years later. Seeing someone talk on the cellphone while riding their bike isn't even shocking in Yellowknife anymore.

But, for all that, I got what I wanted from the book. I fell in love with Japan when we'd visited last year; so much so that we have considered teaching there. But then when the earthquake struck, it looked like teaching in Japan would be off the table forever. For a few brief weeks, Looking for Momo in Tomo Domo, was a pleasant way to experience that dream vicariously. Hopefully it'll suffice until we figure out away to prevent earthquakes and tsunamis.

Have you read a book for the Canadian-Japanese mini-challenge? Make sure to let my know before the month is up!

Labels: , ,

Blogger Kate said...

I don't know if you want us to inform you by e-mail or in these comments, but I have read and reviewed Skim for the Canadian-Japanese mini-challenge.

Thursday, 26 May, 2011  
OpenID niranjana said...

Ditto!
Here's my review of Skim.

Friday, 27 May, 2011  
Blogger Wanda said...

Funny that we both picked decade old books written by teachers for your mini-challenge. It appears I like my choice more than you liked yours.

Ahh chu! No, I'm not kissing up, I just sneezed. Yeah, uhm, cornball doesn't really work for me ...

Wednesday, 01 June, 2011  
Blogger Medea said...

I missed this- what a wonderful challenge. Thank you so much for your support of the relief efforts.

I have a hard time reading teachers-come-to-Japan books, just because they all seem so cartoonish and so away from my experience. Like a car crash though, I can't turn away and have read about 10!

Thursday, 22 December, 2011  

Monday, May 23, 2011

Reader's Diary #715- Nicole Krauss: The Last Words on Earth

(photo by Patric Shaw)

Marking the first post-apocalyptic Short Story Monday post... oh wait, the world didn't end? Ah nuts. At least Nicole Strauss's "The Last Words on Earth" has a fitting title, even if it has nothing to do with the end of the world.

"The Last Words on Earth" begins with a lot of character development for a short story. I kept watching the page counter on the bottom creep along (it's 10 pages) thinking that if she didn't soon get to the plot, she'd be out of time. And the sentence fragments? Egad.

And yet. When the plot came it more than made up for it. In fact, a sense of Leo Gursky, who he is, is integral to the story. As for the sentence fragments? They're him, not Krauss. It's a beautiful story in its sad little life way. It's a funny story in its sad little life way. I'm utterly charmed by it.

(Did you write a post for Short Story Monday? If so, please leave a link in the comments below.)

Labels: , , ,

Blogger JoAnn said...

I loved Leo Gursky, and can't wait to read this story! Thanks.

My post this week:
http://lakesidemusing.blogspot.com/2011/05/morning-walk-by-kate-chopin.html

Monday, 23 May, 2011  
Blogger Loni said...

A short story that takes a long time to get the the point can definitely put me off, but if you're charmed by it, I'm going to have to give it a chance.

Here's my story for this week.
http://loniseye.blogspot.com/2011/05/two-doctors-by-mr-james.html

Monday, 23 May, 2011  
Blogger SuziQoregon said...

I've been thinking about adding short story reviews to my blog and from what I can discover from other bloggers you appear to be host of Short Story Mondays. I'd love to start posting a weekly short story review and this would be perfect. Is there anything particular I need to know or format to follow?

Thursday, 26 May, 2011  

Saturday, May 21, 2011

Under The Midnight Sun Readathon- Are You In?

On July 2nd join me in a 24 hour Canadian readathon! It'll start at noon (your time!) and run until the 3rd at noon. So sleep in after your Canada Day festivities, then wake up and start reading at brunch. Bacon, maple syrup, and a Douglas Coupland novel perhaps? Take a break from reading every hour or two and blog your progress (if you're not a blogger, you can add comments on this site). Give support to others throughout the day. Take pee breaks. But between breaks, it's all about reading Canadian books. Read in your muskoka chair out on the day. Have fun, relax.

And if you're a Canadian Book Challenge 5 participant, what a perfect way to start! Take a few breaks to blog reviews from time to time and those 13 titles will be done in no time. If you're not a Canadian Book Challenge 5 participant, I hope you'll still consider taking part in the readathon. It's a Saturday, it's the summer, what else do you have to do? The lawn can wait.

Sign up in the comments below and help spread the word!

Labels: ,

Blogger Carina said...

I am absolutely in! :-D

Saturday, 21 May, 2011  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

I am going to try! If I can ditch the family and their accompanying demands, that is.

Sunday, 22 May, 2011  
Blogger Heather said...

Count me in. Hubby is off to the north for a firework show so I will be home with the dog and kids. Perfect reading time. This year I am aiming to read books that won The Giller. Have ordered a few, and will be ready.

Sunday, 22 May, 2011  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Awesome everyone, and feel free to use the button above to help get more people on board!

Sunday, 22 May, 2011  
Blogger Gavin said...

I'm in as well! Don't think I'll be able to stay up for all 24 hours though.

Tuesday, 24 May, 2011  
Blogger Melwyk said...

I'm going to try...have to arrange the schedule -- and I learned from my last readathon that it's unlikely I can stay up the entire 24 hrs but I'll give it a good shot anyhow!

Wednesday, 25 May, 2011  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

I posted it A novel Challenge.

Saturday, 04 June, 2011  
Blogger raidergirl3 said...

Normally, I'd be in. School is out for me on June 30th, so all I'm up for that first week of vacation is reading. However.
Guess where I'll be on the July 1st weekend, until the Monday? St Johns! yes, Newfoundland. I've never been, and I am so excited about it.

My son is competing in the Eastern Canadian basketball tourney, Under 14s division. Plus, just my husband (the manager) and I are going; we are leaving the girls home.

Things I need to see? I will be spending lots of time in gyms watching b-ball, but I'll get some time. I know about George Street and imagine the gang of Islanders I'll be with will make a best attempt to get there. Any pubs or shops or food that I will be disappointed if I don't get to?

Saturday, 04 June, 2011  
OpenID emeire said...

I would so love to do it, but I will either be working or at a festival...
Maybe you'll decide to do a winter edition as well?

Sunday, 12 June, 2011  
Blogger Jules said...

I'm in! Can't wait, I've set aside a few books I was planing on reading earlier in the spring for the challenge!

Friday, 24 June, 2011  
Blogger Medea said...

I'm in! I will have to make do with Canadian books I have in the house (mostly kids books!) or those I can download on the Kindle as I won't have time to get anything delivered. So excited to join my first Readathon.

Wednesday, 29 June, 2011  
Blogger April said...

Count me in as well. I borrowed two books from the library today, specially for this challenge and I hope to finish at least one of them. But, I'll probably have to have a bit of a catnap partway through.

Wednesday, 29 June, 2011  
Blogger Jenga said...

I am due to depart on a road trip to the cottage with my cousins at 12pm--- so will be participating, just not blogging. Great way to start my first challenge!

Thursday, 30 June, 2011  

Thursday, May 19, 2011

Canadian Book Challenge 5- Logo Driver's Waltz

With the biggest and best Canadian Book Challenge just around the corner, beginning on July 1st, it's high time we picked a logo. Which of these strikes your fancy the most? Please vote in the comments below! Vote even if you don't plan on joining the challenge, but while we're on the subject, why the heck not join? If you're interested just shoot me an email jmutford [at] hotmail [dot] com with the subject heading Sign Me Up! 13 Canadian books in one year? You can do that!

Labels: ,

Blogger Allison said...

My vote goes to the second one!

Thursday, 19 May, 2011  
Blogger pussreboots said...

I absolutely adore the second one.

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Lahni said...

Totally the second one!

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Jules said...

I also think the second one.

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Luanne said...

And here's another vote for the second one!

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Heather said...

second one. love all those book covers peeking out.

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Chrisbookarama said...

#2 for me too.

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Kate said...

2nd one!

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger John Mutford said...

No one appreciates the ironic first one?

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Gavin said...

Sorry, John. I really like the second one.

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

I like the first one, actually. It reminds me of reading books on an old green chesterfield in the rumpus room.

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Melwyk said...

I do like the first, but for the fifth year of this great challenge, I think the second is perfect!!

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Teena in Toronto said...

I like the second one.

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Nicola said...

the second one!

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Sarah said...

My vote is for the second one as well.

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Steph said...

Like most, I prefer the second one too!

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Carina said...

Number two!

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Sandra said...

Sorry John, I'm sure you worked hard on the first one too but I have to vote with everyone else and say number 2. It's the books that make it.

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Shan said...

#2!

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger raidergirl3 said...

I was coming in to say I liked the first one, and then felt like I must have looked at different buttons. I really liked the subtle V in the corner.
It's not a pity vote either, I really picked the first one.

Friday, 20 May, 2011  
Blogger Charleydog said...

The second one but I would prefer the overall color to be anything but red.

Saturday, 21 May, 2011  
Blogger Swordsman said...

This is a landslide. I vote for #2 too (also?)

Saturday, 21 May, 2011  
OpenID niranjana said...

The second one.

Saturday, 21 May, 2011  
Blogger Suzanne said...

Yep -- #2

Saturday, 21 May, 2011  
Blogger Wanda said...

I like the 2nd logo best!

Sunday, 22 May, 2011  
Blogger GeraniumCat said...

I like the second one too! Challenge V just around the corner, huh? I've got some reviewing to do...

Monday, 23 May, 2011  
Blogger Jonita said...

My vote is for #2 as well!

Wednesday, 25 May, 2011  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

The 2nd one for me as well.

Thursday, 02 June, 2011  
OpenID emeire said...

Sorry for this long absence...
Looks like I agree with the majority!
Em

Sunday, 12 June, 2011  
Blogger Em said...

Sorry for this long absence...
Looks like I agree with the majority!
Em (C'est la vie! http://emeire.wordpress.com

Sunday, 12 June, 2011  

Reader's Diary #714- David Lester: The Listener

A couple of years back my wife Debbie reviewed David Lester's non-graphic novel The Gruesome Acts of Capitalism. It wasn't kind.

Imagine my surprise then when I was contacted by Mr. Lester about a month or so ago, asking if I'd be interested in reviewing The Listener, his new graphic novel from Arbeiter Ring Press. I don't know if he'd forgotten her review, hadn't heard of her review, or just didn't care. I'd like to think it was that last one. It's gutsy and gives me some credit that Debbie and I don't think with the same brain. Yes, we have a lot in common, but we have disagreed on a book or two.

The Listener isn't like any graphic novel I've read before. The artwork in particular isn't consistently styled. It runs from cartoony to sketchy to painty (you can tell my years at art school paid off, eh?). Some drawings are realistic, some are more abstract. But, given that the story revolves around an artist revisiting her reasons for becoming an artist in the first place (I think), the changes are appropriate and added to my interest in the story.

The story itself is not exactly pin-downable. It begins with a protester falling to his death after climbing a sculpture. Wrestling with confusion, guilt, and sadness the sculptor takes off to Europe. There, she coincidentally, or fatalistically, meets a couple that educates her about the events leading to the 1933 election of Hitler. However the plot gets a little hazy along the line and propaganda, spin-doctoring, brutality, dictatorships, and too many other themes start stumbling over one another. At least that's after one reading. The other possibility, and one I'm willing to accept, is that there is a genuine thesis in there somewhere. It's an artistic book, without a doubt, and I don't believe that Lester chose his points randomly. Whether or not it is intentionally abstract or poorly tied together will require more time. Much more time.

Labels: , , , , ,

Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

The variation in illustration style could be a little offsetting, or it could be refreshing, depending on one's mood, I guess. Of course now we all want to know what Debbie thinks of the book.

Thursday, 19 May, 2011  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Barbara: Definitely not for everyone. I don't think Debbie'll be reading it. Though I did get to read Essex County, which she did love, so it's not a graphic novel issue.

Sunday, 22 May, 2011  

Monday, May 16, 2011

Reader's Diary #713- William Lychack: Stolpestad

One of my favourite reasons for hosting Short Story Mondays is the referrals to short stories I'd otherwise most likely miss. Last week Teddy Rose reviewed William Lychack's short story, "Stoplestad" and interestingly, her one quibble with the story which she enjoyed nonetheless, was the 2nd person narration-- which in turn is the thing that piqued my interest the most. I've been finding an increasing number of books and stories written this way over the past year or so and so far, I've enjoyed all of them.

I can't really say that the 2nd person narration in Lychack's story is necessary. Whereas normally I feel such a style forces the reader to become part of the story, I didn't really feel that with Lychack's story. Instead my brain simply translated it into third person, and I moved on. Fortunately it's a great story whatever the narrative perspective.

Stolpsetad is about a cop (the role the reader is supposed to take), on the final hour of his shift on a summer Saturday afternoon. His last call is to handle a situation involving a boy and an injured dog. It's the shifting balance of mundanity and tension that makes the story works so well.

On a personal side, I found myself thinking of my hometown, or more correctly, the place where I grew up-- I haven't really called it home since I moved away almost 17 years ago. And yet, like many of those who grew up in Twillingate, Newfoundland, and like Stolpestad, the police officer in Lychack's story, some people never leave. I'm not judging, I just find it interesting how some people feel the need to go, yet others feel the need to stay. Even people in my family can be divided along these lines-- incidentally, I'm in the minority group. The feeling that I get when I go back to visit must be completely foreign to those who stayed. How about you, did you you move away or stay? Or would you ever go back for good?

(Did you write a post for Short Story Monday? If so, please leave a link in the comments below.)

Labels: , ,

Blogger Julie @ Read Handed said...

I moved out of my hometown about 7 years ago, but only went about 200 miles away. I still visit my family often, but as my life is elsewhere, I find it difficult to stay for longer periods of time. I would move back - my husband and I have talked about it - but it would need to be under the right conditions, i.e. job transfer, etc. I don't think we would just pick and move there.
I talked about John Updike's "A&P" today. You can find it here.

Monday, 16 May, 2011  
Blogger Tea said...

I'm not sure how this meme works. I love to read short stories. I hope in the next couple of weeks to get a handle on how this meme works. The comments are so interesting.

Monday, 16 May, 2011  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Tea: Welcome! Basically all you need to do is read and review a short story (or collection) on Monday and leave a link here. I only do short stories that people can find for free online, but that's not a requirement. I hope you'll consider taking part!

Monday, 16 May, 2011  
Blogger Margot said...

I moved away from my hometown for college and have lived elsewhere ever since. When I married we lived near my husband's hometown and, after a while, that became my hometown. I visit with my family often but they are the reason for the visit, not the place. After 40+ years away, I have no attachment to the place.

I like your comments about 2nd person narration. I'm not sure I've noticed that enough to have an opinion. Now I have to go read the story.

I read and reviewed a Susan Glaspell piece. Your can find it HERE.

Monday, 16 May, 2011  
OpenID carolsnotebook said...

I left my hometown for a few years and then came back.That was like 11 years ago, and I'm still not always sure I made the right decision.

I went with fantasy again this week.

http://carolsnotebook.wordpress.com/2011/05/16/short-story-monday-fair-ladies-by-theodora-goss/

Monday, 16 May, 2011  
Blogger JoAnn said...

I left my hometown when I went to college. Moved farther still when I got married. Now we are back within 20 miles of where I went to high school, but I don't feel much of a connection. My current town is my new "hometown".

Second person narration seems to be gaining in popularity, but I'm not a big fan.

I read Katherine Mansfield this week:
http://lakesidemusing.blogspot.com/2011/05/bliss-by-katherine-mansfield.html

Monday, 16 May, 2011  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

I left my hometown 24 years ago and I rarely go back to visit, now that my family has all moved on to other places. I am happy to be from Winnipeg, but don't feel a pull to live there. Not so for my adopted home, which I still miss, 14 years after moving away.

Off to read your offering!

Monday, 16 May, 2011  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

I thought you would like this one John!

I moved about a 3 hour drive away to go to college. I later moved back near home for a few years and then moved to Vancouver. I have been here almost 20 years now. When I go "home" to visit it just doesn't feel like home anymore. I am a visitor there. Vancouver is home for me. I have a brother who lives here but my other brother and sister still live near the home we grew up in. So we are divided, like yours.

I reviewed Havana: http://teddyrose.blogspot.com/2011/05/havana-by-suzanne-kamata.html

Tuesday, 17 May, 2011  

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Reader's Diary #712- J.K. Rowling: Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire marks the first Harry Potter book I read to my daughter without having read it myself first. When it was published back in 2000, it was the first time I'd even heard of Harry Potter, and because of the crazy hype I decided to go back and read the first 3 in the series before jumping in at the halfway mark. But, feeling pretty blasé about them, couldn't face that gigantic chunkster that brought Harry into my radar in the first place. Of course, since then I've started a family and with my kids discovering Harry, I've grown a larger appreciation and finally took on the 4th book.

Initially, I enjoyed the Goblet of Fire. It was quite action packed and made the length go by quite quickly. I thought the ending, with the villains narrating and explaining everything was clumsy and rather silly, but at least provided some answers. All the dating and Cedric Diggory's death, of course, brought the book up a notch in the maturity, but not so much that my daughter couldn't handle.

After reading the book, we of course watched the movie, and likewise it was okay. It felt a little rushed, trying to cram all that into one movie, and as most of the awe of Hogwarts and the whole concept of an alternate wizarding society has worn off, wasn't quite as magical (pardon the pun). But then Ralph Fiennes somehow managed to pull off that stupid dialogue at the end, and so the magic was regained. And I never pieced it together before now that the same guy that played Cedric Diggory was also that guy from Twilight. Holy cow, he must be rich.

Then the fun came screeching to a halt. The M. Night Shyamalan experience: I thought about it. The Goblet was a portkey, designed to transport Harry away from Hogwarts into the arms of Voldemort. All he had to do was spend the entire book trying to win it, so he would unknowingly touch it and be whisked away. But why not make Harry's toothbrush a portkey? For supervillains they're pretty stupid. Or could it be Rowling? I better watch what I say lest I bring that wrath of the Pott-heads down on me. Going online to see if it was a gigantic plot-hole-- a premise destroying plot-hole-- I was exposed to the scary world of obsessed fans. The first rule of thumb is that Rowling is never wrong. Nothing else could have been made a portkey because... let the theories begin! Except for everyone's rationalization, none of them were explained in the book itself. Surely Rowling couldn't be off the hook for that could she? Are fans willing to have to fill in the blanks? Even worse than the theorists, were those that suggested that anything other than the Goblet would have been too short and what would be the fun in that? Seriously? How about she fix the damn plot hole or else come up with a different plot? Then I got over my frustration with the stupidity that was the Goblet of Fire and instead worried for the sake of humanity at the number of people hating on the (I can't believe I have to add this adjective) fictional Ginny Weasley:
"Stupid b*tch."
"Ginny Weasley is a stupid wh*re."
And that's nothing compared to the fan-fiction. Egad.

Okay, so I didn't like Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire at the end, but it's just a book. Right?

Labels: , , , , ,

Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

It's just a book, yes. I really enjoyed the Harry Potter series, but to be honest, I can never remember which book is which. They all sort of merge into one big (albeit entertaining) romp.

Thursday, 12 May, 2011  

The Great Wednesday Compare #8- Anne Shirley VERSUS Marilla Cuthbert


The winner of last week's Great Wednesday Compare (Anne Shirley VERSUS Vito Corleone), with a final score of 10-0 was Anne Shirley.

Anne takes down the mafia kingpin! Who knew she had that in her? Also interesting that all my voters were female last week. It's not surprising in one sense; since I joined the bookblogging world it quickly became apparent that us male bookbloggers are in the minority by a long shot. But I so badly want to know what the results would have been had the ten votes been male last week. (For what it's worth, I probably would have gone with Anne as well. I've not even read Puzo's The Godfather, I didn't like the movie, and quite frankly I hate mafia stuff. Can't stand it.)

Anyway, this is the official end of the GWC8. With 5 wins under her belt, Anne has is the champion and we retire her...almost. As per tradition, Anne needs to now take on last edition's winner, and holy cow, it's Marilla. Is this even fair? I'm not sure, but let's find out!

Vote in the comment section below before May 17th: Who is the better character?


Labels: , ,

Blogger Megan said...

Oh, geez. So difficult.

I would normally consider this a tie, but I'm going to vote for Marilla.

Wednesday, 11 May, 2011  
Blogger Loni said...

Oohh.. Interesting pairing. I'm going to go with Anne.

Wednesday, 11 May, 2011  
Blogger raidergirl3 said...

No,no it's not fair. At least Matthew isn't anywhere near this.

I think I pick Marilla.

Wednesday, 11 May, 2011  
Blogger Kate said...

I agree that this is the toughest choice in a long time! We see Anne over a much longer span of her life, growing from a girl to an adult to a mother; but Marilla is such a great character and Anne wouldn't have been Anne without Marilla.

I'm going to have to pick Marilla for her wisdom and her humour and her dry cynicism and for the fact that she makes me cry (in the books, not the movies).

Wednesday, 11 May, 2011  
Blogger Allison said...

Argh. Tough call.

I'm going to have to go with Marilla though.

Wednesday, 11 May, 2011  
Blogger gypsysmom said...

Having reached that time of life when I identify more with Marilla than Anne, I'm going to vote fore Marilla. But it's very, very close.

Wednesday, 11 May, 2011  
Blogger Bybee said...

Marilla! Marilla! Marilla!

Wednesday, 11 May, 2011  
Blogger Melwyk said...

For all the reasons everyone has already mentioned, I'll also go with Marilla. Tough call though!!

Thursday, 12 May, 2011  
Blogger Nicola said...

How cool is that for a pairing?! I'm definitely going to have to go with Marilla, too.

Saturday, 14 May, 2011  

Monday, May 09, 2011

Reader's Diary #711- Owen Wister: Mother

Looking for a Mother's Day story I Googled "Short Story" and "Mother" and found "Mother" by Owen Wister, the so-called "father of Western fiction." "Mother," however, is not a tale set in the wild west.

Richard Field and his wife Ethel are guests at a house party. As it is a party of mostly writer-types, each guest is expected to take a turn telling a story. Richard has been instructed to make his true and to make it about himself and an innocent girl as the respective hero and heroine.

There's an air of mystery and tense foreboding at first as Ethel wonders what the story will be. Richard will not tell her, however they come to an agreement that should Richard's tale embarrass her, Ethel may tell one of her own.

I enjoyed all this lead up but unfortunately the mood Wister so carefully established went by the wayside when the tale became one of business; buying and selling stocks, in particular. Perhaps some readers would be intrigued by this, but whenever talk turns to money and investing, my brain shuts down entirely. It's not a good thing and will probably result in my working into my late 80s, but I just couldn't invest my interest in Wister's story. Get it? Invest? Interest? Okay, so I'm bored. Oh and it had as almost as much to do with mothers as this post.

(Did you write a post for Short Story Monday? If so, please leave a link in the comments below.)

Labels: , , ,

Blogger Allison said...

Shame when a story starts out with such promise and then ends in a wash.

Monday, 09 May, 2011  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

I couldn't get all the way through the story, I'll admit. I did find the number of pop-up ads to be rather telling though...

Monday, 09 May, 2011  
Blogger Julie @ Read Handed said...

I posted about a short story today, too. Also about mothers. If you get a chance, it is here.

Monday, 09 May, 2011  
OpenID carolsnotebook said...

Not the kind of story I thought Richard was going to tell based on the setup. It's a shame it was so boring.

My story today is odd. http://carolsnotebook.wordpress.com/2011/05/09/short-story-monday-when-god-opens-a-door-by-tim-waggoner/

Monday, 09 May, 2011  
Blogger JoAnn said...

My mind shuts down when it comes to stocks and investment, too - good thing my husband actually enjoys that stuff.

I read Shirley Jackson this week:
http://lakesidemusing.blogspot.com/2011/05/night-we-all-had-grippe-by-shirley.html

Monday, 09 May, 2011  
Blogger Em said...

I'm back (well, hopefully)!
I have a lot of catching up to do, so I'm sure I will find a story more appealing than this one in the lot. Not that I need any more to be added to my to-be-read list...

Em
http://emeire.wordpress.com/2011/05/10/three-stories-by-jane-urquhart/

Monday, 09 May, 2011  
Blogger Loni said...

I was also uninterested with the story I read this week. I hope next week I find something more exciting.

http://loniseye.blogspot.com/2011/05/bring-forth-wonder-by-george-bowering.html

Monday, 09 May, 2011  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

Boy, I was getting really interested in reading 'Mother', as I was reading your review. Too bad it didn't follow through. Stocks and investment are boring to me as well.

I read a good one, I would love to know your opinion of it: http://teddyrose.blogspot.com/2011/05/stolpestad-by-william-lychack.html

Tuesday, 10 May, 2011  

Thursday, May 05, 2011

Reader's Diary #710- Sylvia Olsen: Yellow Line

I have a comic strip in my head that I can't place. I believe it's set in the desert or some such place and there's a guy with a can marked repellent. One guy comes up to him and asks "what's that?" To which the first guy responds, "shark repellent." "Does it work?" "Well, you don't see any sharks around here do you?" Ba-dump-bump. At least that's the gist. In any case, it's in my head as I consider racism in Newfoundland.

As I've said a few times here on my blog, I grew up in one of the whitest places in Canada: outport Newfoundland. With a near 0% immigrant population, racism was an almost non-issue in my childhood. It put into perspective most of the punchlines on the Jeffersons and when I got older, the context of The Diary of Anne Frank, but it's hard to truly understand racism when you're surrounded by just one race.

I've since lived in many places where this has not been the case. I prefer living amongst other cultures, for the record, but I've also seen the ugliness of racism. Yet, nowhere have I seen it as bad, or at least as blatant, as in Sylvia Olsen's Yellow Line. That's not to say I don't believe the events in Yellow Line couldn't happen in many towns in Canada.

From her website:
The lines that divide are not always solid.
Vince lives in a small town—a town that is divided right down the middle. Indians on one side, Whites on the other. The unspoken rule has been there as long as Vince remembers and no one challenges it. But when Vince’s friend Sherry starts seeing an Indian boy, Vince is outraged and determined to fight back—until he notices Raedawn, a girl from the reserve. Trying to balance his community’s prejudices with his shifting alliances, Vince is forced to take a stand, and see where his heart will lead him.
Yellow Line is a simple read, perhaps too simple at times; sorely lacking in description and the parents lack in psychological depth to make them feel more than one-dimensional. However, it's a story/theme driven story and certainly better than most high interest/low reading level books I've come across. The teenagers felt authentic and the end is hopeful without being unrealistically wrapped up in a happy ending.

Labels: , ,

Blogger Wanda said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

Saturday, 07 May, 2011  
Blogger Wanda said...

The subject matter sounds interesting enough and I'm glad it leaves one with a sense of hope. I'd like to know what my 17-y.o. son would think about the authenticity of teenage charcters in The Yellow Line.

When my oldest daughter was in Sr.High, The First Stone by Don aker was popular with teachers but not so much with students. The problem (as my own daughter so effusively complained) was that the main characters, the teenagers just didn't seem real; their actions and reactions felt forced and the lingo was a little off.

I'm wondering John, if this is one you picked up on your own or if The Yellow Line was one you were curious about because students are reading it (what are their reactions)?

Saturday, 07 May, 2011  

Wednesday, May 04, 2011

The Great Wednesday Compare #8- Anne Shirley VERSUS Don Vito Corleone


The winner of last week's Great Wednesday Compare (Anne Shirley VERSUS Frodo Baggins), with a final score of 7-2 was Anne Shirley.

To be honest, I wasn't sure if Frodo was the right guy from Lord of the Rings to pick to challenge Anne Shirley. I'm not a huge Tolkien fan and I blasphemously like the movies better, but wasn't the whole point of that Fellowship that no one character was really more important than the other? Of course, Frodo's the dude with the ring, but come on Gandalf is a standout too, isn't he? And what about Gollum? I'm not sure. For those of you that voted for Anne last week, was there a Tolkien character that would have changed your mind?

Moving on to the next contender, Anne's messing with the wrong man. Or is she?

Vote in the comment section below before May 10th: Who is the better character?


Labels: , , , ,

Blogger Kate said...

Anne!

(I'm not a huge LOTR fan - books or films - to there's probably not a character there that would beat Anne for me. My sister and I have had some discussions on the topic of Who is the greatest wizard and why - Gandalf, Merlin, or Dumbledore?)

Wednesday, 04 May, 2011  
Blogger Megan said...

Anne!

Wednesday, 04 May, 2011  
Blogger Loni said...

I like strong female characters (I often don't think there are enough in literature) so I might have got with Eowyn from LotR. Gandalf also might have made me change my vote.

I'm sticking with Anne this week.

Wednesday, 04 May, 2011  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

I've not read the Godfather (to be honest,I didn't even know the films were based on a book), so this time around I'll back Anne.

Wednesday, 04 May, 2011  
Blogger Allison said...

Interesting pairing. I'm sticking with Anne though.

Wednesday, 04 May, 2011  
Blogger Sarah said...

I've never read the Godfather, so I'll stick with Anne.

Wednesday, 04 May, 2011  
Blogger Chrisbookarama said...

Aw, look at him holding a kitty! What a nice man.

But I'll stick with Anne.

Wednesday, 04 May, 2011  
Blogger Melwyk said...

Phew, this is easy... Anne!

Thursday, 05 May, 2011  
Blogger Bybee said...

Anne again for me. I don't know if anyone can beat her.

Friday, 06 May, 2011  
Blogger Nicola said...

I love mafia stuff but I've never read or watched The Godfather. So I'm sticking with Anne.

Now if you'd said Tony Soprano ... oh but that wasn't based on a book.

Tuesday, 10 May, 2011  

Monday, May 02, 2011

Reader's Diary #709- Stephen King: Herman Wouk is Still Alive

Thanks to Loni who alerted me to this story last week.

Stephen King's "Herman Wouk is Still Alive," a story about a brutal car accident, the lives of those in the car and of those who witness it, is one of King's more realistic ventures than the supernatural stuff he is most often known for.

It's heavy and emotional and thought-provoking. Thankfully, the comments that follow the story echo many of the thoughts I had while reading, which is a refreshing change from the comments that follow YouTube Videos (last night's most recent comments on Rebecca Black's "Friday" video read "Osama watched this video and killed himself"). At the Atlantic where King's story was published there are, of course, the typical personal insults ("You are a moron."), off-topic chatter, and over-the-top rants, but for the most part people were actually have intelligent discussion about the story, some questioning the same thing I did as I read it. The women driving the car were poor, overweight, one was sexually abused by her father, single parents of a lot of kids, they ate crap, and were quite frankly, stereotypical of lowerclass white folks, or in harsher terms, white trash. Commentators questioned whether or not King could authentically write from such a perspective. He was, apparently, quite poor himself once upon a time, but that doesn't mean he knows what it's like anymore by any means, especially for a single mother. But while those commentators duked it out over whether or not King was perpetuating stereotypes or if he was unfortunately on-the-money, I decided I didn't care. In the context of the story, they were believable characters. I didn't get that King had a checklist of traits he had to ensure made it into the story or that he was making some sort of point on class, I got that he had a story to tell. I find King hit or miss, but I've never found him even remotely pretentious. And this story, dark and cynical as it is, is a hit.

(Did you write a post for Short Story Monday? If so, please leave a link in the comments below.)

Labels: , , ,

Blogger Julie @ Read Handed said...

I participated in Short Story Monday for the first time today. My post is here. Enjoyed your thoughts on Stephen King!

Monday, 02 May, 2011  
Blogger Loni said...

I didn't read the comments in The Atlantic, maybe I will now. I'm glad you enjoyed the story. I also think King has his good and bad, and this was definitely a good story.

This is what I was going to read last week:
http://loniseye.blogspot.com/2011/05/design-for-life-by-emma-jones.html

Monday, 02 May, 2011  
Blogger John Mutford said...

I've been thinking about this story all day (which bumps the story up another notch for me) and I think I sold King short on the thought he put into these characters. There's a question asked at the very end of the story (I won't ruin it for you here) and in hindsight, I think King was really spending the entire story answering that question, for better or worse.

Monday, 02 May, 2011  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

I read Loni's review as well and downloaded the story to read.

I read one Carol's Notebook reviewed a couple of weeks ago: http://teddyrose.blogspot.com/2011/05/ponies-by-kij-johnson.html

Monday, 02 May, 2011  

Sunday, May 01, 2011

The Canadian Book Challenge 4- 10th Roundup!



It's the homestretch, three more roundups (including this one) to go. I'm resisting the urge to start tallying up the final stats already, but I know I'm very impressed-- and not just with the numbers, but also with the well-written, thought provoking reviews, the different books that have been brought to the table, and the general camaraderie amongst the participants.

Over the past couple of months, I've been thinking about Japan a lot and what they must be going through. The physical and emotional toll of what they've had to endure must just be overwhelming. So I had an idea. Next month, instead of offering a book prize, I offer a different kind of mini-challenge. If we can read and review 10 or more Canadian books with a Japan connection, I'll donate $200 to the Red Cross. If we read and review less than ten, I'll donate $10 per book. What's a Japanese connection? If it's written by a 1st, 2nd, or even 3rd generation Japanese Canadian. If it's written by a Canadian but has a Japanese character, or is set in Japan. Perhaps you can find a book by a Japanese author that has a Canadian character, or is set in Canada. How about a book of Canadian manga or Canadian haiku? The connection may be obvious or maybe you'll want to explain it, but in any case it's mostly up to your discretion. I'll be reading the nonfiction book Looking For Momo in Tomo Domo by Nils Andrew Thompson, the true story of a Canadian's experience teaching English in Japan:


But here are a few more suggestions:
2. Joy Kogawa- Many novels, children's books and poetry books to her credit, but her most popular are definitely Obasan and its sequel Itsuka (now renamed Emily Kato):


3. Skim by Mariko Tamaki and Jillian Tamaki

4. Suki's Kimono by Chieri Uegaki and Stephane Jorisch

5. You and the Pirates by Jocelyne Allen





6. Lake and Other Stories by Gerry Shikatani



7. Mannequin Rising by Roy Miki




8. Sidekicks: The Transfer Student by J. Torres and Takeshi Miyazawa

9. The Electric Field by Kerri Sakamoto

10. The Enemy That Never Was: a History of Japanese Canadians by Ken Adachi

These are, of course, but suggestions. Even if you don't plan on participating in this month's mini-challenge, but you know of another book or author we can add to this list, by all means do so in the comments below.

For more ideas on Japanese literature, Canadian connected or otherwise, for ways to help, and for more Japanese reading challenges please check out Tanabata's blog, In Spring It Is The Dawn. She's an ex-pat Canadian who's lived in Japan for 10 years and her blog, started in 2006, is very fun and informative.

And for last month's challenge, a big congratulations goes out to Heather Pearson for winning the Gooselane Poetry Pack!



Soraya Peerbaye Poems for the Advisory Committee on Antarctic Names


Brian Bartlett- The Watchmaker's Table


Katia Grubisic- What if red ran out

I would like to once again remind you that the 5th edition of the Canadian Book Challenge is around the corner. I want to make this one, as it's a milestone of sorts, the biggest and best yet. So please let me know if you're interested in signing up again (email me with the subject "Canadian Book Challenge 5- Sign Me Up!) and if you have any ideas on how to improve, special tweaks or challenges, let me know. Once again, I'm looking for prizes to giveaway so if you're an author, publisher, or bookstore owner, please consider making a donation or two. (Though non-book prizes are also welcome!) Email me at jmutford (at) hotmail [dot] com.

Also, any of you creative types who care to submit a logo idea, I'd be ever so grateful.

One of the new ideas for the 5th Edition? A 24 Hour Canadian Read-a-Thon!!! From noon July 2nd to noon July 3rd, I plan on hosting an online Canadian Read-a-Thon. Are you in? (More details will follow, but feel free to ask questions...)

And finally, while we're all gathered here today: the roundup. What Canadian books did you read and review in April? Let everyone know in the comments below.

Remember:
- Make sure you tell me how many you've completed so far so that I can record it in the sidebar progress report
- It doesn't count as complete until the review is done!
- When people leave links, try to visit one another's blogs and read what they had to say. Comment. Encourage. The discussion of Canadian books is what this challenge is all about.

Labels: ,

Blogger John Mutford said...

Here are my April reads and reviews:

21. Modecai Richler: The Incomparable Atuk

22. Alice Blondin-Perrin: My Heart Shook Like a Drum

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
Blogger Chrisbookarama said...

My daughter read Suki's Kimono. It was cute.

I have another review (that makes 14!):

The Canadian Housewife: An Affectionate History

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
Blogger pooker said...

Hi John and everyone. I'm still here despite appearances to the contrary. I have been reading like a fiend but reviewing like a sloth. Here's two reviews from the not too distant past to bring my total to 15:

14. The Canterbury Trail by Angie Abdou

15. Be Good by Stacey May Fowles

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
Blogger Kate said...

Two more books for me for a total of 23.

22. In Praise of Slow by Carl Honoré

22. Drawn into the Mystery of Jesus through the Gospel of John by Jean Vanier

(I was fasting from fiction during Lent, hence the NF reviews!)

I just ordered a copy of Skim last night, so will be participating in your Japan mini-challenge!

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
Blogger Kate said...

Oops! The Jean Vanier book was #23 (not #22)!

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
Blogger Swordsman said...

This month I only managed one book. Thankfully graphic novels are acceptable. I read Captain Canuck, thanks to a posting I saw in the round-up last month. This brings my total to 15.

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
Blogger Teena in Toronto said...

I read 4 books in April bringing my total to 31 books read ...

"The Top 100 Canadian Singles" (2010) Bob Mersereau
"Driven: How to Succeed in Business and in Life" (2010) Robert Herjavec
"Water for Elephants" (2006) Sara Gruen
"The Guilty Plea" (2011) Robert Rotenberg - I participated in his blogger tour

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
Blogger Sarah said...

My April reviews:

8. Still Missing by Chevy Stevens
9. Snowball, Dragonfly, Jew by Stuart Ross

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
Blogger Nicola said...

Here are my April reads, bringing my total up to 58:

54. Quiver by Holly Luhning
55. Merci Mister Dash! by Monica Kulling
56. The Mystery of Ireland's Eye by Shane Peacock
57. Nearly Nonsense: Hoja Tales from Turkey by Rina Singh
58. High Flight: A Story of World War II by Linda Granfield

PS: If there is a prize this year for most books read, I am removing myself from the running since I won last year.

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
Blogger Shan said...

I read 5 books this month bringing my total to 24.

Arranged by Catherine McKenzie

In From The Cold by Deborah Ellis

There's Lead in your Lipstickby Gillian Deacon

Apocalypse For Beginners by Nicolas Dickner

Doing Dangerously Wellby Carole Enahoro

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
Blogger Melwyk said...

John, you have so many great ideas I hardly know where to begin. Love the Japanese mini-challenge; I'll do my best to join in on that. And I love read-a-thons! Will have to make sure I have that weekend off....

But for now, here are my reads for April, 3 books by Canadian men new to me, for a total of 22:

Into that Darkness / Steven Price

Light Lifting / Alexander MacLeod

The Order of Good Cheer / Bill Gaston

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
Blogger Steph said...

I have four for April:

-Bird Eat Bird by Katrina Best
-Snowball, Dragonfly, Jew by Stuart Ross,
-Better Living Through Plastic Explosives by Zsuszi Garner
-The Incident Report by Martha Baillie (video review!)

I can't remember how to make these links! I'm so sorry! If you go to my blog and click on book reviews, you'll find them there; or scroll through the most recent posts. Off to check out others' reviews!

Also, I think that makes 16 for me since last July.

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
OpenID niranjana said...

I have an interview with Camilla Gibb up at Bookslut, and I also have a review of a talk by three Canadian writers, but I guess neither counts for the challenge?

What might count: Hiromi Goto is a Japanese-Canadian writer; her last book was the YA novel Half World. I'll post a review of that one for the mini-challenge.

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
Blogger Luanne said...

Hmm, I somehow missed posting my March reviews...And it doesn't look like my two in February got added to my total John. ( 19 as of the end of April)

15. Now You See Her - Joy Fielding

16. One Bird's Choice - Iain Reid

17. The Woefield Poultry Collective

And on to April!

18. There's Lead in Your Lipstick - Gillian Deacon

19. The Guilty Plea - Robert Rotenberg

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
Blogger Claire (The Captive Reader) said...

Only one review for April but very appropriate for election season!:

9. The Russian Album by Michael Ignatieff

Sunday, 01 May, 2011  
OpenID fishsauce said...

I'm running way behind this year (posting reviews, not in terms of the reading), but I'm actually at four right now:

1. The Bloodlight Chronicles: Reconciliation, by Steve Stanton

2. One Bird's Choice, by Iain Reid

3. How Should A Person Be?, by Sheila Heti

4. L (and things come apart), by Ian Orti

Monday, 02 May, 2011  
OpenID August C. Bourré said...

Sorry, "fishsauce" was August. Apparently Blogger doesn't let me fill in something that isn't from some other authentication thing, and I never sign up for those with my real names...

Monday, 02 May, 2011  
Blogger Wanda said...

I did manage to get one book review up for April. Miss Elva by Stephens Gerard Malone is my 8th selection for CBC4.

Monday, 02 May, 2011  
Blogger Heather said...

Hi John,
I have sent you a private email with my mailing address. That was my first poetry book in over 20 years. Thanks for the nudge to read it. I wrote a very entertaining review. The author enjoyed it and has agreed to write a guest post for my blog.

14 The Cold Panes of Surfaces by Chris Banks

15 Demon Princess: Reign Check by Michelle Rowen

16 Stone for my Father by Trilby Kent participated in Tundra Books blog tour

Concerning the election, I did read Michael Ignatieff's Scar Tissue, but didn't get the review posted, hopefully today.

Monday, 02 May, 2011  
Blogger Corey Redekop said...

2 more this month. 5, if you count reviews I was actually paid a wee bit for (I don't count those).

15. Room, by Emma Donoghue

16. Sarah Court, by Craig Davidson

Monday, 02 May, 2011  
Blogger Scrat said...

Have been reading a lot but not writing reviews -- noticed that I am still listed at having read 9 -- the total is actually now 14.

Tuesday, 03 May, 2011  
Blogger jeanne said...

Hi John, my April read/review is Pigeon English by Stephen Kelman. This brings my total to a grand 6, not 5. Don't know which one got skipped. Wonderful challenges coming up!

Friday, 06 May, 2011  
Blogger Shannon (Giraffe Days) said...

I keep having trouble leaving comments here, I don't know why!

I've finished my 8th book:

The King's Last Song by Geoff Ryman

I love the new challenge. I have a couple of the books on your list but I think I'm going to read another you didn't mention, Odori by Darcy Tamayose, a Japanese-Canadian. The story is about a Japanese family emigrating to Canada and I think it takes place in both countries.

Saturday, 07 May, 2011  
Blogger Jules said...

Just one book this month for me, now at 17 books!

17) Late Nights on the Air - Elizabeth Hay - This was a great book, the setting reminded be of a book I read last year, Yellowknife.

Sunday, 08 May, 2011  
Blogger raidergirl3 said...

19. Various Miracles - Carol Shields Mar 25
20. The Brutal Telling - Louise Penny Mar 27
21. Waiting for Gertrude - Bill Richardson Apr 10
22. The Night Wanderer - Drew Hayden Taylor May 7

I hadn't updated in a while!

Sunday, 08 May, 2011  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

Congrats to Heather!

I read one in April:
14. Sweet Tooth: In Captivity by Jeff Lemire (Volume 2)

Sunday, 08 May, 2011  
Blogger Buried In Print said...

All the ideas for the 5th sound amazing: I love the idea of a Read-a-Thon, a Canadian one.

Here are my links for March and April:
38. Catherine M.A. Wiebe’s Second Rising (2009)
39. Caroline Stellings’ The Contest (2010)
40. Sharon Jennings’ Home Free (2009)
41. Alice Munro’s Dance of the Happy Shades (1968)
42. Anthony Bidulka’s Amuse Bouche (2003)
43. Alice Munro’s Lives of Girls and Women (1971)
44. Massimo Marcone’s Acquired Tastes (2010)

And, now, onto the homestretch!

Monday, 13 June, 2011